She looked at another member's meal plan, decided the foods looked simple enough, announced she already knew what to do, and walked away. She had been stuck for five years. That conversation is what this episode is about.
In this episode I am breaking down why the single most dangerous belief in the fitness industry is not that results take time - it is the idea that what is standing between you and your goal is more information. More tips. More hacks. A better plan.
If you knew what to do, you would have done it. This episode is the honest conversation about what is actually in the way.
In this episode, we talk about:
- Why the fitness industry profits from keeping you one tip or hack away from a breakthrough
- The data showing internet access nearly doubled obesity rates between 1990 and 2021
- Why GLP-1 medications reverse almost entirely within 18 months of stopping
- Why 63% of gym members quit within the first six months
- What complexity bias is and why your brain gravitates toward complicated plans
- The difference between someone who is learning and someone who is avoiding
- Why collecting information feels like progress but produces the same result as doing nothing
- What the women who actually transform their bodies have in common - and it is not better information
The problem is almost never information. It is almost always implementation. And if you have been collecting tips, saving posts, and listening to podcasts while staying in the same place, this episode is going to explain exactly why.
Ever wish you had a fit and straightforward BFF with over 15 years of experience to help you filter through all the information regarding fitness, nutrition, and life? That's exactly what you'll get when you listen to the Unfiltered Fit Life Podcast.
Join Former Bikini Olympia Champion, mom of 2, and fitness coach Nathalia Melo each week as she shares fitness, nutrition, and life tips to help busy working moms simplify their fitness journey so they can learn easy and simple strategies on how to lose weight and feel sexy AF.
After helping over 5000 busy working moms, Nathalia has found the blueprint to fitness, nutrition, and life success, which she will be sharing in this podcast: actionable tips that will help busy working moms be more present at work and at home.
This show is for you if you realize that nothing good comes from your comfort zone and are ready to challenge yourself to achieve great things. Follow Unfiltered Fit Life wherever you are listening to join us each week for a splash of sass, humor, and a whole lotta truth.
Podcast Transcript
You Know Exactly What to Do. Here's Why That Might Actually Be the Reason You're Not Doing It.
INTRODUCTION AND LISTENER REVIEW
I open by reading a five-star Apple Podcast review from the handle someday I'll be a girl boss, who describes the podcast as having the best inspirational content. I thank listeners for leaving reviews and explain that it is their way of telling the world the content is worth listening to.
THE WOMAN WHO THOUGHT SHE HAD IT FIGURED OUT
I share a conversation that inspired this entire episode. A woman had seen a meal plan created for one of our members and declared she did not need help because she already knew what to do. When I asked how long she had been stuck before seeing that plan she said about five years. I asked her one question - if you already know what to do, why haven't you done it - and the whole episode builds from there.
THE FITNESS INDUSTRY'S INFORMATION TRAP
The fitness industry runs on the idea that you are always one tip, one hack, one secret, or one injection away from a breakthrough. A second conversation with a woman who had been training for seven years, had tried everything, and still reached out looking for my supplement stack, my cardio routine, and my HRT protocol - because she believed the missing ingredient was more information. She also told me she probably already had enough information to be a coach herself. She had been stuck the whole time.
THE DATA
Between 1990 and 2021 internet access grew from 2.6 million people to 4.9 billion worldwide. In that same window US adult obesity nearly doubled, with a 123% increase in men and 100% increase in women. More information did not make us healthier. Unused gym memberships account for approximately 1.8 billion dollars in annual spend in the United States. 63% of gym members quit within the first six months and only 18% go consistently. 80% of January gym signups are gone before summer.
THE GLP-1 DATA
While people lose an average of 15 kilos on semiglutide or tirzepatide, they regain nearly 10 kilograms within the first year of stopping. Researchers estimate people return to their starting weight within a year and a half to two years of stopping - and the weight regain is faster than after ending behavioral weight loss programs. A co-author of the Lancet study noted that newer GLP-1 drugs are not going to be the magic bullet. The most powerful weight loss drug ever created almost entirely reverses within 18 months of stopping because the drug never taught the body or brain anything new and never addressed the behavior.
COMPLEXITY BIAS
There is a psychological concept called complexity bias - the tendency to favor more complex solutions over simple ones because complexity is perceived as more credible or effective. This is why people gravitate toward the most complicated new protocol on social media and why the simple plan that actually works feels too easy to trust. Complexity is also a form of procrastination - a complicated plan gives you a built-in excuse to keep preparing instead of doing.
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN LEARNING AND AVOIDING
Collecting information can feel like diligence. The color-coded notebooks, the spreadsheets, the saved Instagram posts - it looks like preparation but at some point it becomes a way to stay in motion without actually doing anything. There is a real difference between someone who is learning and someone who is avoiding using the appearance of learning. When was the last time you got new information and actually changed your behavior because of it and stayed consistent for a year - not a month, a year?
WHAT ACTUALLY WORKS
The women who transform their bodies are not the ones who found the best information or the best hack. They are the ones who stopped looking for more information and asked the simplest possible question - what is the simplest way I can do this so I can stay consistent with it. Most high-performing women already know the fundamentals. The problem is not information. The problem is which part of all that information applies to me and how do I implement it in the life I actually have.
THE IMPLEMENTATION GAP
What most people need is not more information - they need a way to implement what they already have. They need a way to filter out what is relevant to them and what is not. They need support to adapt the plan when life changes - when the kids are off school, when work explodes, when someone gets sick, when a vacation happens. A plan that only works when nothing else is going on is not a plan. Certainty on the process does not come from more information. It comes from starting, getting evidence that you can be consistent, and building trust in yourself through action.
CLOSING
I close by bringing it back to the woman at the beginning. You do not need me to tell you that squats are good for you. What you need help with is the implementation, the behavior patterns, the schedule optimization, the accountability, and the adaptation when life happens. If you are ready to stop collecting information and start implementing, there is a link in the show notes to book a clarity call.
How to Lose Fat & Get Lean After 40
When Your Hormones Have Changed & It Feels Like Nothing Works Anymore
