Interviews

Midlife Dating Unfiltered: Nathalia & Coach Jen Tell It Like It Is

Midlife Dating Unfiltered: Nathalia & Coach Jen Tell It Like It Is
Are you stepping back into the wild world of modern dating, especially in midlife? Maybe you’ve been out of the game for years and are shocked at how much things have changed. If dating today feels more like navigating a minefield than finding a match, you’re not alone.

In this episode of the Unfiltered Fit Life podcast, I’m bringing back the incredible Coach Jen to get real about what it’s like to re-enter the dating scene after a long-term marriage. We’re diving into the highs, the lows, and the WTF moments of post-divorce dating—because, let’s be honest, it’s not always smooth sailing.

From online dating nightmares to redefining self-worth and mastering better communication, we tackle the critical lessons that shape relationships after divorce. Whether you’re already swiping right or just thinking about dipping your toes back in, this conversation is packed with insights you need to hear.

Listen on: Spotify |  Apple

Here’s what we’re breaking down:
  • The real challenges of dating in midlife (and how to navigate them).
  • Why setting boundaries and maintaining self-respect is non-negotiable.
  • The power of personal accountability and self-improvement in relationships.
  • How to communicate with confidence and build genuine connections.

Let’s be real—dating today can feel like a total rollercoaster, but at the end of the day, it’s about knowing yourself and what you actually want in a partner. Owning your worth, setting clear boundaries, and refusing to settle? That’s how you take control of your dating journey.

Women are putting a price tag on themselves. Regardless of how high that price tag is, it's still a price tag when we should always present ourselves in a priceless manner. - Coach Jen

So tell me—what’s your strategy for maintaining (or rediscovering) your self-worth in the dating world? Let’s chat about it on Instagram!

Meet Jennifer Lawson

Jennifer is the head coach of the Powerhouse Academy. She is a licensed counselor with over 17 years of experience in fitness. She has worked on the gym floor. She has done fitness competitions. She also works in her private practice as a licensed counselor with teens and young adults aged 13 to 25.

Connect with Nathalia

Get my favorite pre-workout HERE

Instagram

LinkedIn

Facebook

Website

Thanks for joining us on the Unfiltered Fit Life podcast! If you enjoyed this episode, please leave us a rating and review on Apple and Spotify to help us reach even more women ready to simplify their fitness journey so they can lose weight, regain their confidence, and feel sexy AF!

More about the Unfiltered Fit Life podcast

Ever wish you had a fit and straightforward BFF with over 15 years of experience to help you filter through all the information regarding fitness, nutrition, and life?

That’s exactly what you’ll get when you listen to the Unfiltered Fit Life Podcast. 

Join Former Bikini Olympia Champion, mom of 2, and fitness coach Nathalia Melo each week as she shares fitness, nutrition, and life tips to help busy working moms simplify their fitness journey so they can learn easy and simple strategies on how to lose weight and feel sexy AF. 

After helping over 5000 busy working moms, Nathalia has found the blueprint to fitness, nutrition, and life success, which she will be sharing in this podcast: actionable tips that will help busy working moms be more present at work and at home.

This show is for you if you realize that nothing good comes from your comfort zone and are ready to challenge yourself to achieve great things. Follow Unfiltered Fit Life wherever you are listening to join us each week for a splash of sass, humor, and a whole lotta truth. 

This episode is brought to you in partnership with Leah Bryant Co.

The podcast transcript for this episode of the Unfiltered Fit Life podcast follows

Nathalia [00:00:01]:
Hello, hello there, fam! Welcome to another episode of The Unfiltered Fit Life Podcast. I'm Nathalia Melo, your host.

Today, I have Coach Jen back on the show! I think we need to create a fun, sassy name for these episodes since she’s joining us regularly. So if anyone has an idea, send me a message! What should we call these segments?

Jen’s Thoughts on Today’s Topic

Jennifer Lawson [00:00:31]:
I feel like this episode deserves a special title once we’re done with it!

Why We’re Talking About Dating in Midlife

Nathalia [00:00:35]:
Jen and I have been discussing this topic for a while. I’ve been married for almost ten years, but Jen has been divorced for six years. We frequently talk about her experiences in the dating world, and let me tell you—I am flabbergasted by the nonsense she deals with.

Since we also have many members in the Powerhouse Academy who are midlife and navigating dating again, I thought it would be important to have this conversation. Many people assume that divorce is the ultimate solution and that life will instantly be better on the other side. While in some cases, divorce is necessary, it’s not always the magic fix people expect.

Jen, as someone who’s been on both sides—married and now single—what were your biggest surprises when reentering the dating scene?

The Reality of Dating After Divorce

The Biggest Shock: Lack of Respect and Communication

Jennifer Lawson [00:02:12]:
Oh goodness, where do I start? Just to give a little background—I was married for ten years, and I’ve now been divorced for six years. Dating again has been an experience, to say the least.

The biggest shock? A complete lack of respect on both sides.
✔️ Women presenting themselves with little self-respect and not understanding why.
✔️ Men not respecting women at all.

And communication? Painful. People no longer know how to have basic conversations.

The Struggles of Dating Apps

Jennifer Lawson [00:02:54]:
These days, most people meet through dating apps rather than organically. Some people still meet in person, but I’m not at the bar scene at 10 or 11 PM anymore—sorry, I’ve been asleep for hours at that point!

Nathalia [00:03:20]:
Right?! By that time, it's basically wake-up time for the next day.

Jennifer Lawson [00:03:22]:
Exactly! So you’re on these apps, and the way men approach you is ridiculous. The most common opening line? "Hi." That’s it. No effort. Or sometimes, they’ll say, "Crazy weather today, huh?"

Nathalia [00:03:57]:
The fuck?!

Jennifer Lawson [00:03:59]:
Right?! Like, that’s the best you can do?

Nathalia [00:04:00]:
That’s so unoriginal. I mean, at least "What are your weekend plans?" is slightly better, but still.

Jennifer Lawson [00:04:21]:
Even when I respond, the conversation goes nowhere. They give one-word answers and make no effort to actually get to know me. That’s why my dating profile is clear—I give men one week to engage in real conversation and set up a date. If they don’t? Unmatched.

The Lack of Respect in Modern Dating

Being Propositioned Like an Object

Nathalia [00:05:19]:
When you say "lack of respect," what do you mean exactly?

Jennifer Lawson [00:05:37]:
Oh, let’s start with the fact that I’ve literally been propositioned—as in, men offering material things in exchange for my time.

✔️ I’ve had men say, "I’d love to spoil you, as long as you wear heels."
✔️ I’ve been invited to be the third person in a married couple’s arrangement.
✔️ I’ve had men imply that they could "take care of me" financially.

The Rise of Transactional Relationships

Nathalia [00:09:20]:
This reminds me of something I saw on social media. There’s a woman I follow named Nadia (don’t agree with everything she says), but she once pointed out that many relationships today are explicitly transactional.

🚹 The man offers money.
🚺 The woman offers beauty.

And the moment he loses his money, he’s no longer valuable. The moment she ages, she’s no longer valuable to him. It’s a mutual transaction, not a relationship built on real connection.

Jennifer Lawson [00:12:49]:
Exactly! Women are literally putting a price tag on themselves, whether they realize it or not. And when you allow yourself to be "bought," that’s all the man sees you as—an object with an expiration date.

How Women Can Take Back Their Power

Defining Your Own Worth

Nathalia [00:14:30]:
Women need to stop accepting crumbs and start seeing things for what they really are. If a guy only values you for what you look like, guess what? He’s going to replace you the second that fades.

Jennifer Lawson [00:15:17]:
Yes! Too many women are so desperate for attention that they accept any attention—whether it’s good or bad.

Elevate Yourself First

Nathalia [00:58:04]:
I had a conversation with a new member in Powerhouse Academy recently. She told me, "I know that when I elevate myself, I’ll start attracting people who match that energy."

👏 YES! That’s where many women miss the mark. If you want to attract a high-value partner, you need to become a high-value person first.

Final Thoughts: Lessons from Dating & Divorce

Key Takeaways from Jen’s Journey

Nathalia [01:05:33]:
Jen, if you could go back and give your newly single self one piece of advice, what would it be?

Jennifer Lawson [01:05:54]:
✔️ You can’t fix people.
✔️ Don’t ignore red flags.
✔️ Stop making excuses for men who aren’t putting in effort.

Would You Get Married Again?

Nathalia [01:02:45]:
Would you get married again?

Jennifer Lawson [01:02:53]:
Absolutely. 100%.

I’ve learned so much from my past that I now understand what real commitment looks like. The first time around, I didn’t. Now, I get it.

Respect Yourself & Set Standards

Ladies, your worth isn’t based on whether a man chooses you. Take care of yourself. Set boundaries. Stop tolerating less than what you deserve.

Join the Conversation!

💬 Have you experienced these dating struggles?
📩 DM me on Instagram and let me know what resonated with you.

Thanks for listening, and Jen—thank you for sharing your insights! Can't wait for our next episode. 🎙️

Up next

Trying to Eat Healthy & Get Back on Track? You Need to Hear This